Passive RFID Tags vs. Active RFID Tags

Passive RFID Tags

Passive tags are comprised of three elements: an integrated circuit or chip, an antenna, and a substrate.

The RFID chip stores data and performs specific tasks. Depending on its design, the chip may be read-only (RO), write-once, read-many (WORM), or read-write (RW). Typically, RFID chips carry 96 bits of memory but can range from 2-1000 bits.

Attached to the chip is the antenna, whose purpose is to absorb radio-frequency (RF) waves from the reader's signal and to send and receive data. Passive RFID tag performance is strongly dependent on the antenna's size: the larger the antenna, the more energy it can collect and then send back out. Larger antennas, therefore, have higher read ranges (although not as high as those of active tags).

Antenna shape is also important to the performance of the tag. Low- and high-frequency (LF and HF, respectively) antennas are usually coils because these frequencies are predominantly magnetic in nature. Ultrahigh-frequency (UHF) antennas, on the other hand, look similar to old-fashioned TV antennas ("rabbit ears") because ultrahigh frequencies are solely electric in nature.

The third component of a passive RFID tag is called a substrate, which is commonly a Mylar or plastic film. Both the antenna and the chip are attached to the substrate, which may be thought of as the "glue" that holds all of the tag's pieces together.

In contrast to active RFID tags, passive tags are usually smaller and less expensive.

Active RFID Tags

Like passive RFID tags, active tags have both a microchip and an antenna. The chips, however, are usually larger in size and have greater capabilities than the RFID chips in passive tags.

Active tags have two additional components that differentiate them from passive tags: an on-board power supply and on-board electronics.

The power supply is usually a battery, although it can also be solar. The built-in power supply allows the tag to transmit data to a reader on its own, without the need to draw power from the reader itself like passive tags do. In addition, active tags can be read from distances of 100 feet or more, whereas passive tags can only be read from up to about 20 feet.

On-board electronics may consist of sensors, microprocessors, and input/output ports, all of which are powered by the tag's on-board power source. The electronics allow active RFID tags to be used in a wider range of applications than passive tags. For example, perishable food products may be tagged with sensors that collect data that can then be used to determine expiry dates and warn the end user that the item may be spoiled. Even though many products have expiration dates printed on them, these dates are valid only if the product is stored under the optimal conditions (temperature, humidity, exposure to light, etc.) for that type of product. Thus, the product may expire before the printed date if it is not stored properly. An RFID tag equipped with a temperature sensor might be able to predict the actual expiration date of a carton of milk, for example, which may be very different from the printed date.

Whether you choose to use active or passive tags in your RFID system will likely depend on both your particular application and your budget.

Simple asset tracking that utilizes barcode technology will become obsolete as RFID proliferates through organizations, making them more efficient and better equipped for accuracy.

<< Back to Articles

As the complexity and scale of the RFID application increases, so does the challenge of estimating its total cost of ownership. Our team of consultants can assist you in performing a cost-benefit analysis for your intended application.

If you have more questions, contact the RFID experts at American Barcode & RFID.